Well, I'm sitting outside my lecture hall waiting for my 4pm class to begin, and as I have no desk to work with, I can't actually study. So instead, I am going to discuss my just-finished contemporary anthropology tutorial. Otherwise known as "how to have a controversial opinion. On EVERYTHING".
I love the class itself. I like most of the readings.
What I hate is the types of discussions (pardon me, discourses) that occur in the tutorials. Its as if everyone has to have an avant garde opinion on anything and everything. All things must have a deeper meaning and an ulterior motive. Nothing can just be what it is.
Drives me a little bonky, to be completely honest.
Take today's discussion. Topics: National Geographic, FGM and "West is the Best" concepts.
To start at the beginning. Apparently National Geographic is Satan.
I love National Geographic. I think the articles are interesting, the photographs are gorgeous, and its a basic look at a lot of interesting topics. It isn't meant to be a textbook on a subject.
The TA (and the article we read, and most of the students in the tutorial-most of whom are seemily just trying to agree with everyting the TA says for brownie points) is under the impression that the mag is continually and purposefully misrepresenting cultures and cultural genders in order to control western women.
Excuse me, WHAT?
Apparently the representation of differently attired African women is mean as a means to sexually control Western women. African women are photographed topless because all NG photographers are (knowingly or not) googling pervs who see a boob and decide to centre their feature around that.
Never once in tutorial or in the article is it mentioned that African women often DO dress differently than Western women. Sometimes, they don't wear tops.
But isn't that to be expected. They are a different culture.
If anything, the exploitation and misrepresentation are (in my opinion) on the part of a bunch of scholars clamoring to see racism and exploitation in everything that portrays anyone who is unlike them. Instead of admiring the beauty of other culture, of other styles and of other lives, many immediately jump on the 'its bad' bandwagon.
The discussion then turns to how the magazine is sexist since male genitalia are not portrayed. In fact, they are often artfully concealed.
Again, is anyone surprised by this. The breast is generally considered a great deal more acceptable to depict than a penis. Also, female genitalia are not portrayed either.
So the problem isn't the portrayal of topless women, but the fact that men aren't photographed naked as well? Riiiight.
And on the discussion goes, until we reach the concept of FGM. For those of you who don't know, that's female genital mutilation.
The Eurocentrism really begins to rage here.
FGM is bad. Its barbaric. It must be stopped.
....
No mention of male circumcision? Hello?
Orite. Western people have decided that's ok, so its ok. Its only FGM thats bad, since western people have decreed it to be so.
Think anyone bothered to present the (very contensious) opinion that FGM is cultural. It belongs to a culture that ISN'T OURS! To understand if its something that must be stopped, shouldn't we be asking the women in the cultures where it DOES occur. Find out what THEIR thoughts on the procedure are?
This is glossed over. Largely because a lot of women in these cultures see it as a rite of passage. Its something they want to do.
Now, don't get me wrong. I dont' think it should be done to 6 year olds. Its not something I would want myself. But if a consenting adult female CHOOSES this, who are we to tell her she is wrong? That it's bad or exploitative?
Its interesting, because as soon as the conversation turned to veiling in other cultures, everyone jumps to the proverbial other side of the boat.
All of a sudden, everyone is *screaming* that we need to respect the culture, we need to allow the women to choose for themselves. This is something many women consider beautiful and desirable and want for themselves.
OK, so if its a headdress, women should be respected and have the choice. If its body modification (of a sort that we don't like), women need to be 'saved' and interventions need to be held.
It all seems very backwards to me. Then again, so does the rest of the discussion. We jump from critiquing the portrayal of other cultures by NG, to saying that other cultures and their ideas of beauty must be respected.
If we respect it, why can't we portray it? If choice for one's body is choice for one's body, why are only some modifications "OK"?
Wednesday, January 25, 2012
Week off
So I've had the past week and a half (almost 2 weeks) off work from the SC. Have been working my regular shifts at K, but thats it. 10 hours a week. Fab.
Mostly for reasons I will not go into here...most of you already know.
So am I *excited* to go back to work? No. I've grown weary of that job, the double standard and the bottom-of-the-barrel treatment. I'm looking elsewhere. Somewhere that might be a little more intellectually stimulating, while still allowing me to go to school.
School itself is looking up. Finally, as of yesterday, sorted out all of the administrative issues I've been having. My courses are all sorted out, the overcharge on my student account is dealt with, and now all I have to do is catch up. I just got (back) into one of my classes. I have 2 weeks of work, plus this weeks, to finish by Friday. I set the time limit myself, so I don't fall continually behind. I'm a geek. I like to have all of my assigned readings done BEFORE I go to class; that way I can make reference in my notes to what I've already read, instead of trying to go back and do it all later. I now just have to narrow down my ideas for a research topic.
I've got it down to 3.
- How to assess and combat HIV/AIDS in marginalized communities.
- Healthcare and genocide. How is it provided during and in the aftermath of these events, and how is health effected in a long term sense?
- Westernized vs. Indigenous medicine and healthcare. Which is more effective, in what situations? Can the two be married to provide the best healthcare for a community?
Problem: I want to do them all. I can't choose a topic. So which do you think is most interesting???
Mostly for reasons I will not go into here...most of you already know.
So am I *excited* to go back to work? No. I've grown weary of that job, the double standard and the bottom-of-the-barrel treatment. I'm looking elsewhere. Somewhere that might be a little more intellectually stimulating, while still allowing me to go to school.
School itself is looking up. Finally, as of yesterday, sorted out all of the administrative issues I've been having. My courses are all sorted out, the overcharge on my student account is dealt with, and now all I have to do is catch up. I just got (back) into one of my classes. I have 2 weeks of work, plus this weeks, to finish by Friday. I set the time limit myself, so I don't fall continually behind. I'm a geek. I like to have all of my assigned readings done BEFORE I go to class; that way I can make reference in my notes to what I've already read, instead of trying to go back and do it all later. I now just have to narrow down my ideas for a research topic.
I've got it down to 3.
- How to assess and combat HIV/AIDS in marginalized communities.
- Healthcare and genocide. How is it provided during and in the aftermath of these events, and how is health effected in a long term sense?
- Westernized vs. Indigenous medicine and healthcare. Which is more effective, in what situations? Can the two be married to provide the best healthcare for a community?
Problem: I want to do them all. I can't choose a topic. So which do you think is most interesting???
Wednesday, January 18, 2012
Quick Ranty-Rant
Dear Professor who couldn't be bothered to respond to my emails (regarding a rather time sensitive issue) in a timely manner. Your apathy has cost my not only a space in the class that I dearly wanted to take, but also caused me issues with scheduling regarding my OTHER classes. Had you responded that, despite my extensive course repetoire, you would not waive the prerequisite (an introductory level course) for YOUR course, I would have unenrolled, and scheduled my other courses accordingly. But you didn't respond. Either with an OK, or a no. So I left well enough alone, contacted my TA for another course to sort out the *conflict* and scheduled around your class.
Lo and behold, the issue was never addressed, so the course registration server dumped me out of the class, enrolled another student, and thorougly effed up my entire day. I go to speak with you, and not only do you not bother acknowledging my email to you, but you pay me not even half of your attention and respond rather carelessly that *if* another space opens, I can contact the department, who will submit my transcripts to you for consideration and you will consider allowing me to take your class. It is now the second week of class. Going through the department takes at least 10 days. Thus we are talking about a further 2 weeks before I have an answer-a full month into the class.
Professor, I am an honours graduate of this university. I have taken no less than 7 introductory level courses, 3 of which DIRECTLY pertain to the subject matter your class covers. I am not a first year with no qualifications clamouring for a spot in a 3rd level class.
Now, I know I am not entitled to take your class without the prerequisite. But I do think I am entitled to two minutes of your attention, a cursory glance at my record and a straighforward YES or NO answer as to whether I may be reinstated to my spot in your class that I was so unceremoniously dumped from.
Sincerely,
Me
Lo and behold, the issue was never addressed, so the course registration server dumped me out of the class, enrolled another student, and thorougly effed up my entire day. I go to speak with you, and not only do you not bother acknowledging my email to you, but you pay me not even half of your attention and respond rather carelessly that *if* another space opens, I can contact the department, who will submit my transcripts to you for consideration and you will consider allowing me to take your class. It is now the second week of class. Going through the department takes at least 10 days. Thus we are talking about a further 2 weeks before I have an answer-a full month into the class.
Professor, I am an honours graduate of this university. I have taken no less than 7 introductory level courses, 3 of which DIRECTLY pertain to the subject matter your class covers. I am not a first year with no qualifications clamouring for a spot in a 3rd level class.
Now, I know I am not entitled to take your class without the prerequisite. But I do think I am entitled to two minutes of your attention, a cursory glance at my record and a straighforward YES or NO answer as to whether I may be reinstated to my spot in your class that I was so unceremoniously dumped from.
Sincerely,
Me
Somehow molecular Biology always comes back to haunt me!!
Its happened again. My quasi arch-nemesis, molecular biology is back in my life. This time in the guise of immunopathology. Now, before you say anything, I realize immunopathology is based largely on cell and molecular level biology. However, I had forgotten (read, repressed) the fact that molecular bio makes up 90% of the course material.
The class is super interesting, and what is especially cool is each lecture is taught by a different professor. Meaning that if one professor doesn't teach in a style you like or pick up well, you won't have him/her for more than one or two lectures. Plus, each topic is taught by someone who is researching in the area themselves!!
I am going to have to do some heavy cramming on the molecular aspect though-its been YEARS since I have taken a course related to that!!!!
In shittier news, my job at S has turned into something from the seventh level of hell. The hours (for me at least) have dried up because boss 'can't afford' to give me any time for the next 2 weeks due to a large tax bill. I'm sorry, but how is that MY problem!!!!!! Blargh! Well, at least its prompted me to engage in a much needed and long overdue job hunt. Now perhaps I can work in something slightly more related to what I've been (an continue to be) educated in. Then again, given the state of the job market and economy currently, that might be a bit of a pipe dream.....
I'm also picking up my volunteer component for my med application soon. Its not doing what I initially thought I might (Meals on wheels or the like) but is instead with a community focued group-which may actually be better, since the med school I'd like to go to has a focus on students who wish to remain within the community. Anything to improve my chances!!
In current news/ranting, I've just in the last hour heard about the SOPA legislation in the States. Censoring the internet....woooonderful idea. I've blacked out my facebook page in protest, although I will admit that I can't fully boycott-with my being in class today, I have to use google, my course pages and student email server at very least.
Anyway, back to the immunology books! Ciaobella :)
The class is super interesting, and what is especially cool is each lecture is taught by a different professor. Meaning that if one professor doesn't teach in a style you like or pick up well, you won't have him/her for more than one or two lectures. Plus, each topic is taught by someone who is researching in the area themselves!!
I am going to have to do some heavy cramming on the molecular aspect though-its been YEARS since I have taken a course related to that!!!!
In shittier news, my job at S has turned into something from the seventh level of hell. The hours (for me at least) have dried up because boss 'can't afford' to give me any time for the next 2 weeks due to a large tax bill. I'm sorry, but how is that MY problem!!!!!! Blargh! Well, at least its prompted me to engage in a much needed and long overdue job hunt. Now perhaps I can work in something slightly more related to what I've been (an continue to be) educated in. Then again, given the state of the job market and economy currently, that might be a bit of a pipe dream.....
I'm also picking up my volunteer component for my med application soon. Its not doing what I initially thought I might (Meals on wheels or the like) but is instead with a community focued group-which may actually be better, since the med school I'd like to go to has a focus on students who wish to remain within the community. Anything to improve my chances!!
In current news/ranting, I've just in the last hour heard about the SOPA legislation in the States. Censoring the internet....woooonderful idea. I've blacked out my facebook page in protest, although I will admit that I can't fully boycott-with my being in class today, I have to use google, my course pages and student email server at very least.
Anyway, back to the immunology books! Ciaobella :)
Saturday, January 14, 2012
Jan 14th
Well, its the new year now. My new years resolution was to spend more time on things I enjoy, and finish some of my craft projects...my knitting, cross stitch, catch up on some books, try the new recipes I've been wanting to check out, walk more, and keep up with this blog a bit more.
Clearly, thats been going GREAT! Its the 14th of the month, and this is my first post in over a month.
Its been hectic. Christmas was its usual insanity, with the added excitment of a hospital visit. Turns out, I have PVST which is exacerbated by stress and caffeine.
Worth has been a mind-fuck lately, and its not helped by the fact I can no longer have my morning latte. I finally have a few days off though, which is great.
I'm also back at school now, which is the greatest thing since sliced bread. 10 months off is too long, and hopefully I'm not out for that long again (at least until I finish med school!)
Ian is signed up for his first round of police recruiting (yaay!) and we've managed to get ourselves on a budget-quite strict but its saving us a LOT of money.
Nothing much exciting has occurred in the last wee bit, just a lot of work and house cleaning!
Today has been a day off, and I'm making chicken soup and trying a new recipe for sweet and sour pork for dinner.
We finally have some snow down, which means I can get a picture of our house all decked out for Christmas finally!!!!
Clearly, thats been going GREAT! Its the 14th of the month, and this is my first post in over a month.
Its been hectic. Christmas was its usual insanity, with the added excitment of a hospital visit. Turns out, I have PVST which is exacerbated by stress and caffeine.
Worth has been a mind-fuck lately, and its not helped by the fact I can no longer have my morning latte. I finally have a few days off though, which is great.
I'm also back at school now, which is the greatest thing since sliced bread. 10 months off is too long, and hopefully I'm not out for that long again (at least until I finish med school!)
Ian is signed up for his first round of police recruiting (yaay!) and we've managed to get ourselves on a budget-quite strict but its saving us a LOT of money.
Nothing much exciting has occurred in the last wee bit, just a lot of work and house cleaning!
Today has been a day off, and I'm making chicken soup and trying a new recipe for sweet and sour pork for dinner.
We finally have some snow down, which means I can get a picture of our house all decked out for Christmas finally!!!!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)